Forumics logo Forumics
Issue 01

Back to issue

All Codex known issues

CLAIM C108 Supported 2026-11-13

GitHub issue #42695 in openai/codex, opened 2026-09-04 by HS7097, records a report that a task delivered through `send_message_to_thread` on Codex Desktop on Windows (bundled CLI 0.153.0) was received and partially executed correctly, but after automatic mid-turn compaction the receiving agent reverted to an older, already-completed instruction instead of finishing the current task; that its final response then incorrectly reported that no task execution had occurred, despite successful tool results and files created earlier in the same turn; that the incoming Task B instruction was recorded as a `function_call_output` associated with `send_message_to_thread` while the replacement history retained the older Task A instruction as a visible user message; and that the opaque compaction item's contents cannot be inspected, so the report does not establish that Task B was entirely absent from the compressed summary. The report notes whether this shares a root cause with related reports requires investigation, and no root cause is asserted.

Verbatim Excerpts from Cited Records
“A task delivered through `send_message_to_thread` was received and partially executed correctly. After automatic mid-turn compaction, the receiving agent reverted to an older, already-completed instruction instead of finishing the current task.”
— HS7097 · openai/codex (issue 42695 opening body, Summary section) · 2026-09-04T07:34:12Z ·GitHub Issue ↗
“Its final response then incorrectly reported that no task execution had occurred, despite successful tool results and files created earlier in the same turn.”
— HS7097 · openai/codex (issue 42695 opening body, Summary section) · 2026-09-04T07:34:12Z ·GitHub Issue ↗
“The incoming Task B instruction was recorded as a `function_call_output` associated with `send_message_to_thread`.”
— HS7097 · openai/codex (issue 42695 opening body, Local Evidence section) · 2026-09-04T07:34:12Z ·GitHub Issue ↗
“The observable failure is that the post-compaction continuation followed an obsolete instruction and produced an inaccurate execution report.”
— HS7097 · openai/codex (issue 42695 opening body, Local Evidence section) · 2026-09-04T07:34:12Z ·GitHub Issue ↗
Counter-record: Issue open as of the fetch; 22 comments were read. github-actions[bot] (2026-09-04) flagged potential duplicates #42051 and #42611. 345180376-web (2026-09-06) added two independent macOS observations on bundled CLI 0.153.4. FrankHZ (2026-09-11) reproduced the failure on Windows with bundled CLI 0.153.4. HS7097 (2026-09-13) reported the failure absent during experimental context management and returning with conventional compaction. IvanKashitskii (2026-09-16), andriyo (2026-09-29), javadavado-svg (2026-10-03), blockjacc (2026-10-03), phoenixweiss (2026-10-03, 2026-10-18, 2026-10-28), bobbyleeweiwei-bobby (2026-10-08), realgyeongminnoh (2026-10-13), RongNianXin (2026-10-14), kilalice (2026-10-21), kkonstvol-lab (2026-10-21) and rossky094-hub (2026-10-23) added further independent macOS and Windows reproductions through 2026-10-28. bfpbr5 (2026-10-27) proposed a root-cause candidate on where the initial context is re-inserted after compaction. heyxjacob (2026-11-05) added compatibility evidence on bundled codex 0.166.0-alpha.6. masonturveysonicdiy (2026-11-11) reported a further incident on 2026-11-11 and a reversion in the next turn. javadavado-svg (2026-11-12) reported 9 stale-response episodes across monitored chats between 2026-11-05 and 2026-11-11. No maintainer fix and no retraction of the report appear in the surveyed thread. The claim documents only the original report, not a verified current state. Falsification probe: If GitHub issue #42695 is deleted without archive, if the author edits the opening body so the quoted sentences no longer match verbatim, or if the author posts a retraction of the report, this claim drops to Withdrawn. Audit verification: Verified 100% continuous verbatim substring against official GitHub REST API by scripts/verify_claim_verbatim.py.

See also: Codex vs Cursor head-to-head comparison on 9bests